The Riksdag said no to the strategy and urged the government to come back with a revised ANDTS strategy where it is clear which different initiatives are to be implemented and where responsibility for the initiatives should lie.

In addition to this, the Riksdag also called for the strategy's overall goals to take into account that different nicotine and tobacco products can cause different levels of harm, that the National Board of Health and Welfare should be tasked with clarifying the scientifically proven differences in the degree of harm caused by ANDT products, and that a national competence center for prevention should be established to quality-assured and further develop ANDTS prevention methods.

37 members from all parties except the Social Democrats and the Green Party voted in favor of the Social Affairs Committee's proposal to reject the bill. The Social Democrats' and the Green Party's 19 members voted against.

Compact dissatisfaction

During the debate that preceded the decision, it became clear that dissatisfaction with the proposed ANDTS strategy was widespread from all parties except the government parties. Several members called for greater clarity regarding concrete actions and who is responsible for them.

Of the government parties, the Social Democrats only participated in the debate with an introductory speech by Yasmine Bladelius. It was the Green Party's Nicklas Attefjord who led the discussion with Johan Hultberg (M), Pia Steensland (KD), Karin Rågsjö (V) and Anders W Jonsson (C).

The debate came to be largely about the drug part of the strategy and to a lesser extent about tobacco, although Nicklas Attefjord in his opening speech reviewed the tobacco industry's strategies to attract new users. The purpose of the proposal for the ANDTS strategy is to protect children and young people from their own and others' harmful use, he said.

– I want to remind you that the tobacco industry is cynical and corrupt, it has bought and bribed scientists, politicians and judges around the world, and caused the premature death of millions of people. It spreads smoke screens in order to continue developing and selling its products, which should be introduced as early as possible so that customers become addicted and the money can tick in, month after month, he said.

Several members raised the issue of distinguishing the harmfulness of different tobacco products.

– Snus is definitely not a health product, but comparing snus with cigarette smoking, which is one of the biggest public health threats, is misleading, said Anders W Jonsson (C), for example.

Karin Rågsjö made a point against those members who do not keep their distance from the tobacco lobby.

"We are often courted by various lobbyists, such as Philip Morris and the snus manufacturers, who are now also represented by a doctor. I think lobbyists from the tobacco and alcohol industries should be kept at a reasonable distance from politics," she said.

“Success for the snus lobby”

The fact that the different health hazards of different tobacco products will be made visible in a revised strategy is a success for the snus lobbyists, according to Margaretha Haglund, Tobacco Facts' tobacco policy expert.

– We are also very disappointed with the muddled strategy that the government presented, but the problem that has now arisen is that the snus industry is getting its chance to continue to mislead the Moderates, the Sweden Democrats, the Christian Democrats and the Center Party with the harm minimization concept. Everyone knows that snus is less dangerous than burnt tobacco, but what are the effects on children and what is the signal if a product like snus, which is highly addictive and harmful to health, is given a cream cheese spread over even worse tobacco products?

– It becomes a kind of indirect approval of snus when children assess the risks. It is not possible for party representatives to claim to care for children while at the same time wanting to facilitate the snus industry's products. The Social Democrats should have been much more active and present in the debate and not just let the Green Party defend the strategy, she says.

According to the Tobacco Control Convention, public health policy should be protected from the tobacco industry and decision-makers should avoid meetings with representatives from it. In practice, it is clear that these guidelines are not being followed.

– It is frightening that our elected officials have so little knowledge about the tobacco control convention. The ignorance makes you sad. In 2005, the Riksdag voted that Sweden should join the tobacco control convention, which also applies to snus. Only the Moderates were against it, says Margaretha Haglund.

read on